Wall Street pares gains after trade-fueled rally

U.S. stocks gave up early gains on Thursday, as a rally sparked by progress in U.S.-China trade talks faded, with investors moving into defensive sectors such as real estate and utilities.The S&P 500 <.SPX> posted its best one-day percentage gain in 10 days on Wednesday following President Donald Trump's upbeat comments on trade and Beijing's first major purchase of U.S. soybeans in months. However, trading has been increasingly choppy and the major stock indexes have given up most early gains in the past two sessions. On Thursday, the defensive consumer staples <.SPLRCS>, utilities <.SPLRCU> and real estate <.SPLRCR> were leading gains among the 11 S&P sectors, which indicate caution, according to Crit Thomas, global market strategist at Touchstone Investments in Cincinnati."We have news coming out of China that suggests they want to play nice and make amends. But there is a narrative growing that there might be a recession in 2020," said Thomas."So it's hard for the market to really get excited when you have that sort of a narrative hanging out there." The markets have also reacted to a slew of headlines ranging from a potential U.S. government shutdown, interest rates to uncertainty around Brexit.The U.S. Treasury yield curve will invert next year, possibly within the next six months, much earlier than forecast just three months ago, with a recession to follow as soon as a year after that, according Reuters poll showed.